Could black box evidence prove liability in a Pennsylvania accident?

Proving what caused an accident is often difficult. The data contained on a vehicle’s black box recorder may contain crucial data that another driver was negligent.

Almost every car that comes equipped with an air bag has a black box recorder similar to that of an airplane. These devices capture information about speed and braking maneuvers as well as throttle position and other technical details. Data from the seconds before a crash can help experts determine the cause of an auto accident.

In a Pennsylvania case from several years ago, black box information used in a criminal case helped prosecutors secure a vehicular homicide conviction. Three passengers in the vehicle died after the car struck a concrete barrier and flew into a wooded area.

The way that the car left the Pittsburgh highway after hitting the barrier told authorities the vehicle was traveling at a high speed. Because the car was airborne for many feet before it crashed, investigators did not have tire tracks or skid marks to determine exact speed.

Police obtained information from the black box recorder that the car was traveling 105 mph. The driver’s attorneys challenged the use of this data and filed an appeal. The Pennsylvania court of appeals affirmed the conviction finding that black box data collection systems were well-established technology. The decision was the first appellate decision to review the use of black box data in criminal prosecutions.

Upcoming federal requirements

General Motors first installed black boxes or event data recorders in its vehicles to track the speed of a vehicle and deploy airbags in an accident. When a crash happens and an airbag deploys the device provides information from a few seconds before the crash. Often this information helps determine what caused the collision.

No standard exists for the industry, so different automakers track different data. In 2012, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration proposed a rule that would require every new car to contain a black box that would provide five seconds of data on 15 different elements before a crash. In 2015, the recorders will be mandatory for all vehicles. A couple automakers, such as Mercedes-Benz and Audi, will have to start installing the devices in their vehicles.

Civil case liability determinations

When it is unclear whether the negligence of another driver caused a car crash, the seconds of data before a crash contained on these recorders can be incredibly valuable. Obtaining the information needs to be completed quickly or it may be lost. Often these devices record over past data. The court may need to order another party to turn over the black box recorder in some cases.

When an injury is serious, you may not recall the moments immediately before or after the accident due to shock. Seek the assistance of a personal injury attorney in dealing with insurance companies and finding the cause of the crash. You might be entitled to monetary damages to cover lost wages, medical expenses and the suffering you endured because of the accident.

Keywords: car accident, causation, serious injury



2 men sitting at a table

Basic Steps to Selecting the Right Attorney

Online, on TV, on billboards, on radio, you face a constant barrage of ads promoting attorneys. How can you know which one is the right one for you?


At Goodrich & Geist, we believe that there are three basic qualifications individuals seeking an attorney should always look for.


“We had a wonderful experience working with this firm. Josh Geist was professional, easy to talk to, answered all our questions, and was forth coming with all that was going on. We would highly recommend him to anyone looking for an attorney who truly has your best interest at heart.”

More Client Reviews

We Are Leaders in THE FIELD OF Personal Injury

We are considered leaders in our own profession. We give lectures on personal injury law and teach other lawyers the nuances of how to build solid cases, secure evidence and obtain successful outcomes — all in an effort to see that more injured victims receive justice. We also take an active role in relevant legal associations.

Our Approach


When you’re choosing an advocate to fight for your rights, the first question you want to ask is, “Does this attorney understand someone like me?” and “Have they had success in handling a case like mine?”

Case Results


Maybe our FAQ will help